We own a townhouse in Portland. The amount we owe is 60k more then what we could sell for. We are in the process of buying a second house and we were planning on renting the townhouse. We have had a few friends and even co-workers tell us to just foreclose on the townhouse. We can not make in rent what we owe for the mortgage (we’d be paying $600 a month on the mortgage still), and we’d have to carry it for at least five + years to be at a point where we could sell it. What are the implications of foreclosure? How will this affect us if we go this route? (I know it will affect our credit scores for 10 years, but what else will it do?) Carrying both houses will be very difficult. With a renter we can make it work. Before you ask, we are moving because the neighborhood the townhouse is in is very bad. We are dealing with drugs and a lot of police activity on our street daily. This is not something we decided lightly. I feel terribly guilty even thinking about foreclosure, but I’m having doubts that renting is the best option for us either. I’m just looking for some advice, maybe someone who’s gone through this, and might have some perspective? Thanks
The Quicken Loans person is wrong in that you would be "walking away from any equity you have".. you already said you owe more than it is worth, therefore you have negative equity.
Here is what I recommend: Rent the home with a lease, and use the shortfall as a Loss on your income taxes. You will also be able to write off the depreciation on the house, starting with the year you start to use it as a rental. Keep track of any costs associated with it as a rental house: your mortgage, interest, taxes, insurance, maintenance, advertising, etc. Then keep track of the rent you get. Keep track of the bills and then write off the bills if you will be paying utilities like water, once it turns into a rental.
You might be able to have a decent write off and save on taxes making the $600. shortfall actually less, plus at the same time building equity hopefully in the future, and if the market goes back up, who knows maybe even get a profit?
As time goes by, rents go up. You might be able to charge $50. a month more in rent amount, next year and so forth, until the time which you can sell the house for what you owe.